Walk down any wellness aisle and you’ll see both: snacks and drinks that promise “more than nutrition,” and capsules, gummies and powders that say “dietary supplement” on the label. They can look alike and even contain the same ingredients. So what actually separates them?
The short answer: in the US, the law sets the difference, not the ingredients. And the easiest place to spot it is a small box on the back of the package. Here’s how it works, in plain words.
What is a functional food?
A functional food is a food that offers something beyond basic nutrition. Think of yogurt with live cultures, oats with their natural fiber, or cacao with its natural plant compounds. You eat it as part of your normal diet, the same way you’d eat any other food.
Here’s the surprise: in the US, “functional food” is not a legal category. The FDA has no official definition for it. Brands use the term mostly in marketing. In the eyes of the law, a functional food is simply a food, and it follows all the same rules as any other food:
- Every ingredient must have FDA approval for use in food or count as “generally recognized as safe” (GRAS).
- The label carries a Nutrition Facts panel.
- Any claim about how it supports the body has to come from the food’s nutritive value, and it can never say the food treats or prevents a disease.
Other countries do things differently. Health Canada, for example, has its own definition, and Japan has a special category for foods with approved health claims.
What is a dietary supplement?
Unlike “functional food,” “dietary supplement” is a legal term. Congress defined it in the Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act of 1994 (DSHEA). In simple words, a dietary supplement is a product you take by mouth that:
- contains one or more dietary ingredients: a vitamin, a mineral, an herb or other botanical, an amino acid, or a concentrate or extract of these;
- aims to add to your diet, not to be a regular food or a whole meal;
- says “dietary supplement” on the front of the package.
Supplements are often capsules, tablets or gummies, but they don’t have to be. A supplement can also look like a food, such as a bar or a bite, as long as the brand doesn’t sell it as a regular food.
Two more things set supplements apart:
- They can talk about more than nutrition. A supplement can describe how an ingredient supports the body even when the effect isn’t nutritional. A food can only do that based on its nutritive value.
- That comes with extra rules. The brand must notify the FDA within 30 days of using such a claim, and the label must carry the FDA disclaimer you’ve probably seen: “This statement has not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration…” Foods don’t need either.
How to tell them apart on the label
Flip the package over. A food has a Nutrition Facts panel. A supplement has a Supplement Facts panel. A product can’t be both, so this one box tells you which it is. The two panels look similar, but they follow different rules:
| Nutrition Facts (food) | Supplement Facts (dietary supplement) | |
|---|---|---|
| Where you’ll find it | Snacks, drinks, everyday foods, functional foods | Vitamins, botanicals and other products that say “dietary supplement” on the label |
| What’s listed | Calories and nutrients with a Daily Value, like fat, carbs, sugars and protein | The same nutrients, plus ingredients with no Daily Value, like an herbal extract, with the amount per serving |
| Source of an ingredient | The panel can’t list it | The panel may name it, for example “vitamin C (as ascorbic acid)” |
| Part of the plant | The panel can’t list it | The panel must name it, for example “milk thistle (seed)” |
| Nutrients at zero | The panel shows “0 g” | The panel leaves them out |
| Claims and the FDA disclaimer | Claims must come from nutritive value. No disclaimer | Claims can go further, with the FDA disclaimer and a notice to the FDA |
Tip: if you want to know exactly how much of an active ingredient you’re getting, a Supplement Facts panel will tell you, per serving.
Which one is right for you?
Neither is “better.” They do different jobs.
- A functional food fits into what you already do. You eat it the way you eat anything else, so it’s easy to make a daily habit. Choose one when you want everyday food that gives you a little more.
- A supplement centers on specific ingredients and amounts. The Supplement Facts panel tells you exactly what you get per serving. Choose one when you’re looking for a particular ingredient at a stated dose.
And the format isn’t the deciding factor. A supplement doesn’t have to be a pill: it can come as a gummy, a powder, or a piece you enjoy like a treat.
Where Smart3® fits
At Smart3® we make both, from the same functional cacao base, in our own facility. Here’s how to tell them apart:
- Naked Nature® is a food. It’s our functional cacao on its own, with no added active ingredients, so it carries a Nutrition Facts panel.
- CHOCOWellness® and SHARP are dietary supplements. They start with the same cacao and add active ingredients for a specific goal, so they carry a Supplement Facts panel that lists each active and its amount per piece.
Same taste, same daily ritual. The panel on the back tells you which one you’re holding.
Quick answers
Is “functional food” an official FDA category?
No. In the US it’s a marketing term. Legally, a functional food is a regular food and follows the same rules.
Can a product be both a food and a supplement?
No. It’s one or the other, and the panel on the label shows which: Nutrition Facts or Supplement Facts.
Does a supplement have to be a pill?
No. Supplements can be capsules, tablets, powders, liquids, gummies or even bites, as long as the label says “dietary supplement” and the brand doesn’t sell them as a regular food.
Why do some labels have an asterisk and an FDA statement?
Supplements that describe how an ingredient supports the body must carry the statement “This statement has not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration.” It’s a legal requirement, not a warning.
Sources
- FDA: Questions and Answers on Dietary Supplements
- FDA: Dietary Supplement Labeling Guide, Chapter IV (Supplement Facts vs. Nutrition Facts)
- FDA: Notifications for Structure/Function Claims in Dietary Supplement Labeling
- FDA: Structure/Function Claims
- National Academies: legal definition of a dietary supplement (DSHEA, 1994)
- Husch Blackwell: Understanding functional food categories
- NutraIngredients-USA: Functional foods around the world
Made in our own facility
Food or supplement? We make both.
Every Smart3® product starts with the same FoodBIOME® cacao. Naked Nature® is the food. Our formulas add ingredients for a specific goal.
Chococeutical Innovations, LLC makes Smart3® products in Sarasota, Florida. These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. Smart3® products are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease.


